A reader asked me if there’s any reason not to use TD Ameritrade for a solo 401k. TD Ameritrade offers many Vanguard ETFs commission-free. For more on solo 401k in general, please read Solo 401k When You Have Self-Employment Income.
When I looked into the solo 401k documents from the big 5 solo 401k providers — Vanguard, Fidelity, Schwab, TD Ameritrade, and E*Trade — I noticed one thing. Even though their basic prototype documents are more or less the same, different providers serve as different roles in section 8 of the adoption agreement.
|Provider||Role||Allows Roth||Allows Loan|
Vanguard and Fidelity serve as the trustee. Schwab, TD Ameritrade, and E*Trade serve as the custodian. What’s the difference? The plan document has a long list of responsibilities for the trustee and another long list of responsibilities for the custodian. I’m not a lawyer. I don’t pretend to be able to match the fine prints and tell the difference.
I’m hoping that by highlighting this difference in the role each provider assumes, someone who knows better will be able to shed more light on this.
Practically speaking, regardless the legal role, is the scope of services any different at different providers?
I only had my solo 401k at Fidelity. I know what it does for the plan. If you have a solo 401k plan at Vanguard, Schwab, TD Ameritrade, E*Trade, or any other provider, please help me with these questions from your experience with the provider:
1. Who’s the provider?
2. What’s on the title of the account? Besides the name of the plan, is the participant’s name also on the account?
Fidelity has both on the account. If husband and wife both participate, they must have separate accounts and it’s very clear which account is under whose name.
3. If you are using the Roth option in your solo 401k, is the word ‘Roth’ actually on the account? If the word ‘Roth’ isn’t on the account, how does the provider know it’s Roth?
Fidelity doesn’t have the Roth option.
4. When you contribute to the plan, is there a process that tells your provider which plan year, which participant, and what contribution type it was for (employee vs employer, pre-tax vs Roth)?
Fidelity has a paper form for this. I heard some providers don’t track. You just put money into the account(s).
5. What document(s) do you receive after the end of the year besides the normal account statements?
Fidelity sends a valuation report with the total beginning and ending balances, total contributions received, total distributions paid, and the total earnings, both for the plan as a whole and a breakdown for each participant.
6. If you take money out of the plan, does the provider file the necessary tax forms with the IRS? If you use the Roth option, you need the tax forms to reflect it’s Roth so that you won’t pay tax on the distribution.
I haven’t taken any money out yet but I believe Fidelity will file the necessary tax forms.
I don’t know whether the mere legal role “trustee” or “custodian” makes all the difference in practice. You still need to understand the scope of services, especially when it comes to tracking different contribution types and issuing tax forms.
Schwab, for example, asks for a second EIN for the plan separate from the EIN of the employer, whereas when you use Vanguard or Fidelity you only need one EIN for the employer. That’s because Schwab only serves as the custodian, whereas Vanguard and Fidelity use their trust company Vanguard Fiduciary Trust Company (VFTC) and Fidelity Management Trust Company (FMTC) respectively for issuing tax forms.
TD Ameritrade and E*Trade both allow loans from the solo 401k plan. I can’t imagine they will be tracking how much was issued as a loan, how much of a deposit was loan payment, how much was interest and how much was principal, how much of the loan is paid off so far, and how much of the loan is still outstanding. If you liquidate the account, the outstanding loan balance has to be part of the distribution. Without accurate tracking, they won’t be able to issue accurate tax forms. Does that mean they won’t issue tax forms anyway, with or without a loan?
Before we have clear answers, I would suggest sticking with Vanguard, Fidelity, or Schwab for your solo 401k.
[Photo credit: Flickr user Shimelle Laine]
Say No To Management Fees
If you are paying an advisor a percentage of your assets, you are paying 5-10x too much. Learn how to find an independent advisor, pay for advice, and only the advice.