Last week I wondered in a comment to a post on The Simple Dollar about what the FDIC insurance claims process is really like when a bank fails. If a bank fails, do you get paid right away, or do you have to wait until everything is sorted out? For how long? How do you prove how much you had in your account if the bank’s computer is screwed up because the bank failed?
As if I jinxed it, there was news report about a bank failure in Pittsburgh on the same day. It was the first bank failure in the country since June 2004, no less. Here’s an excerpt from the news report on Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:
“Mr. Cavacini is one of 1,453 Metropolitan Savings account holders tangled up in the first Pittsburgh-area bank seizure since the collapse of FS&LA of Pittsburgh in 1991 — and the first in the United States since June 2004. The Pennsylvania Department of Banking shut down the Lawrenceville bank Friday and handed the keys to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.”
So there we have it, a perfect example to study what really happens when a bank goes out of business and how the FDIC protects the bank customers. On Friday Feb. 2, 2007 the Pennsylvania state bank regulators shut down Metropolitan Savings Bank and gave control over to the FDIC. The FDIC quickly solicited bids from other banks and awarded the failed bank to another bank, Allegheny Valley Bank, which operates in the same town. Allegheny Valley Bank and FDIC personnel moved in to the failed bank, took the weekend to organize the books and re-opened the failed bank as a branch of Allegheny Valley Bank on the following Monday. That was quick! All customers of the failed Metropolitan Savings Bank became customers of the succeeding bank Allegheny Valley Bank.
However, some 70 unlucky customers had balances over the FDIC insurance limit at the failed bank. They will become creditors to the failed bank. The FDIC will sell off the the failed bank’s assets and pay them from the proceeds. That process can take years. The lesson learned? Don’t keep over $100,000 at any bank — not a problem for me because I don’t have that much money!
Bank failures are rare but they still happen. According to the FDIC, there were 28 bank failures since October 2000, averaging 4-5 a year. In most cases, the FDIC would arrange another bank to take over the deposits at the failed bank and the customers continue on without harm. When the FDIC couldn’t find a buyer, it paid out the insured balance from its own fund (for example, NextBank failure in 2002). This fast action gives me comfort in the system. One of my questions remains unanswered:
How do you prove how much you had in your account if the bank’s computer is screwed up because the bank failed?
I think for this reason, I will continue to favor larger international or national banks over smaller no-name banks. Because security and control are largely a fixed cost, in other words, a bank needs to invest in more or less the same level of security and control whether it has 10,000 customers or 10,000,000 customers, a larger bank will have more resources for security and control.
- Failed Bank List from FDIC, with links to what happed to each failed bank.
- Frugal Frugalson writes about personal experience in a bank failure
Say No To Management Fees
If an advisor is charging you a percentage of your assets, you are paying 5-10x too much. Learn how to find an independent advisor, pay for advice, and only the advice.