Opening an account at TreasuryDirect to buy I Bonds is an easy process for most people. It takes less than 15 minutes (see How to Buy I Bonds). However, a small percentage of people run into an issue with ID verification. They are asked by TreasuryDirect to get a signature guarantee on a paper form FS 5444.
Automated ID Verification
TreasuryDirect uses an automated third-party service to run ID verification. Many other financial institutions do the same for opening accounts online. Your account is kicked off to an exception process when the automated service says they can’t verify your identity based on the given information.
When this happens at other financial institutions, they may ask you to upload pictures of your driver’s license or show up at a physical branch with your ID. Because TreasuryDirect doesn’t have any physical branch, they ask you to get a signature guarantee on a paper form and mail it to them.
Unrelated to Credit Freeze
Failing ID verification isn’t caused by having a credit freeze. You can still pass with a credit freeze in place. You don’t need to unfreeze your credit before you open an account with TreasuryDirect.
It has more to do with matching your name, date of birth, Social Security Number, driver’s license number, address, and phone number. If you moved recently, the ID verification service may fail you because they don’t have the updated information yet. Or perhaps the ID verification service simply doesn’t have all the information for everyone. It’ll return a failure when it can’t match the information.
It’s not your fault. The automated ID verification service just isn’t 100% reliable. You’ll have some extra work if you’re unlucky.
No Longer Required for Changing Bank Account
TreasuryDirect used to require a signature guarantee on Form FS 5512 when you wanted to change the bank account linked to your account. This is why you should choose a bank account that you intend to use for a long time when you open your TreasuryDirect account. Changing it down the road may require more work.
[Update on December 12, 2022:] TreasuryDirect can change the linked bank account online now. Go to ManageDirect and then Update my Bank Information.
Not Required for Cashing Out
Once you have the TreasuryDirect account set up and the bank account linked, buying more I Bonds or cashing out won’t require a signature guarantee again unless your account runs into other problems.
Cashing out (redeeming) is handled by the automated system. When I cashed out I Bonds some time ago, the money showed up in my linked bank account the next business day.
Certifying Officer or Notary
The latest edition of the Account Authorization form FS 5444 requires a signature guarantee from either a certifying officer at a financial institution or a notary. Getting it signed by a notary public is easier than getting it from a bank or credit union. Make sure you download the latest FS Form 5444.
Other TreasuryDirect forms don’t accept a notary stamp. You still need to get it signed and stamped by a certifying officer at a financial institution.
You don’t need to go to a place where you have an account, although being a customer certainly helps. They’re only doing you a favor because TreasuryDirect isn’t paying them and they have no obligation to do it. It’s easy for them to say no for fear of liability or simply because they haven’t seen it before.
Any Bank Works
The financial institution you go to get a signature guarantee doesn’t have to be the same bank or credit union you use in your TreasuryDirect account. If you use an online bank in TreasuryDirect, you can go to a different bank with a brick-and-mortar branch for the signature guarantee. If one bank refuses you, you can go to another bank.
If you go to a bank or a credit union, talk to someone working at a desk, not a teller. The teller may not be familiar with it. Try to catch someone more experienced who may have done it before. Ask nicely. If you get a “no” from someone, try a different branch or go to a different bank. Try a credit union or a small community bank, which may be more community-minded and willing to go the extra mile.
When I needed it, I made an appointment at a Bank of America branch and they did it for me.
Not a Medallion Signature Guarantee
TreasuryDirect asks for a signature guarantee, not necessarily a medallion signature guarantee. A medallion signature guarantee is one form of acceptable signature guarantee but it’s not the only one.
A medallion signature guarantee is a program of the securities industry. It’s used more for transferring brokerage accounts. If your broker has a physical branch near you, you can try it there but many brokers only give medallion signature guarantees when it involves their own accounts. They don’t do it for outside accounts. If you have large accounts at the broker, they may agree to make an exception.
Many banks and credit unions don’t give medallion signature guarantees but the [normal] signature guarantees they give for signing checks or cashing savings bonds will work for TreasuryDirect. So don’t start your conversation at a bank or a credit union by asking for a medallion signature guarantee. Simply say you need a signature guarantee.
Mail and Wait
If you succeed in getting a signature guarantee from someone willing to accommodate, now you mail it to the address on the form and wait. It may take a month for TreasuryDirect to complete the process. You’ll receive an email when it’s done.
I had to do this recently for changing the linked bank account. I mailed the form on December 20th. It was processed on January 4th. The turnaround time isn’t too bad, considering the mailing time, the holidays, and the flurries of activities at the end of the year. Just have some patience and let the process run its course.
Say No To Management Fees
If you are paying an advisor a percentage of your assets, you are paying 5-10x too much. Learn how to find an independent advisor, pay for advice, and only the advice.