How Does Claiming Social Security Affect ACA Health Insurance?

I mentioned in the previous post When to Claim Social Security: How Much Does It Matter, Anyway? that a common recommendation for a married couple is for the lower-earning spouse to claim Social Security early at 62, and for the higher-earning spouse to delay claiming until age 70. Several readers raised a concern that claiming Social Security at 62 may raise the ACA health insurance premiums. The same concern also applies to a single person considering claiming at 62.

We’re assuming that you’re not working when you’re considering claiming Social Security at 62. Otherwise, the Social Security earnings test may apply, which defeats the purpose of claiming at 62. When you’re not eligible for Medicare yet, you’ll most likely buy health insurance from the ACA marketplace unless you have retiree health insurance or you’re covered through your spouse.

ACA Premium Subsidy, Cliff or Ramp?

How does claiming Social Security affect the ACA health insurance premiums? It depends on your household income. I had this chart in my post The ACA Premium Subsidy Cliff After the 2025 Trump Tax Law:

The federal government is currently shut down due to disagreements in how ACA health insurance premiums will be structured in 2026 and beyond. The blue line in the chart represents the law in effect in 2025. As your household income increases, your ACA health insurance premiums also increase on a ramp. The orange line represents what will happen in 2026 and beyond if Congress doesn’t pass a new law to stop it. The ACA health insurance premiums will be higher at all income levels, and then suddenly jump up a cliff when your household income exceeds 400% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL), which is $62,600 for a single-person household, and $84,600 for a two-person household, in 2026.

The first question is whether there will be a cliff.

Suppose there is a cliff (the orange line), and your household income is already over the cliff before claiming Social Security (the flat part of the orange line). In that case, you’re already paying the full price without any premium tax credit. Receiving additional income from Social Security will NOT affect your ACA health insurance premiums.

Suppose there’s no cliff (the blue line), or suppose there’s a cliff, but your household income will still be below 400% of FPL after claiming Social Security (the left part of the orange line). In that case, each $100 of incremental income from Social Security will increase your ACA health insurance premiums by $10 – $20.

If there’s a cliff (the orange line), and claiming Social Security will push your household income from below the 400% of FPL cliff to above it, your ACA health insurance premiums will jump a lot. That’ll make it not worth claiming Social Security at 62.

Household Income	Cliff	No Cliff
> 400% FPL before SS	No Effect	Increase by 10% of the incremental income
< 400% FPL after SS	Increase by 10-20% of the incremental income	Increase by 15-20% of the incremental income
Cross 400% FPL with SS	Huge Jump	Increase by 10-20% of the incremental income

Replacing or Increasing Income?

Note that the table above says “incremental income.” The incremental income isn’t necessarily 100% of the Social Security benefits you’ll receive. The incremental income can be zero or negative if receiving Social Security will only replace other income.

Where does your household income come from before claiming Social Security?

Case 1. Suppose you’re withdrawing from a pre-tax account, such as a Traditional IRA, to cover living expenses before claiming Social Security. A $20,000 withdrawal counts as $20,000 of income for ACA health insurance. You don’t need to withdraw as much to cover living expenses now after you claim Social Security. $20,000 in Social Security benefits also counts as $20,000 of income for ACA health insurance. Your income stays the same when you replace the same amount of withdrawals from a pre-tax account with Social Security.

The IRS taxes at most 85% of Social Security benefits, while many states don’t tax Social Security. In contrast, pre-tax account withdrawals are fully taxable by the IRS and most states. When you receive $20,000 in Social Security benefits, it can replace maybe $22,000 in pre-tax account withdrawals to cover the same amount of living expenses.

Your incremental income will be negative, and your ACA health insurance premiums will decrease if you replace a larger amount in pre-tax withdrawals with Social Security benefits.

Case 2. Suppose you’re selling appreciated investments in a taxable account to cover living expenses before claiming Social Security. Only the capital gains portion counts as income for ACA health insurance. Suppose your investments comprise 30% as cost basis and 70% as capital gains. $14,000 from selling $20,000 worth of investments counts as your income for ACA health insurance.

You don’t need to sell much to cover living expenses now after you claim Social Security. $20,000 in Social Security benefits counts as $20,000 in your income for ACA health insurance. Replacing investment sales with Social Security will increase your income, but by much less than 100% of the Social Security benefits.

Case 3. Suppose your current household income comes from a pension, rental income, interest and dividends, and other income that can’t be stopped after claiming Social Security. In this case, 100% of the Social Security benefits will be incremental income.

Source of Income Before SS	Incremental Income
Pre-tax account withdrawals	Zero or negative, after reducing withdrawals
Selling investments in a taxable account	Partial, after reducing investment sales
Unstoppable income	Full

How Many Years on ACA Health Insurance?

Claiming Social Security at 62 versus claiming at 65 when you qualify for Medicare will potentially affect your ACA health insurance premiums for 3 years. If you have a younger spouse who’s also on ACA health insurance, claiming early could affect your ACA health insurance premiums until the younger spouse is also 65. The more years you’ll use ACA health insurance, the more impact there may be from claiming Social Security at 62.

Compare with Delaying Social Security

I ran a test case in Open Social Security for a married couple, both born in 1964 (will be 62 in 2026). One spouse has a Primary Insurance Amount of $2,000 per month, and the other has $3,000 per month. The recommendation from Open Social Security is for the lower-earning spouse to claim at 62 and for the higher-earning spouse to wait until 70.

If the lower-earning spouse waits until 65, this couple would still receive 98.7% of the maximum present value from Social Security. The difference in the total present value is $9,470 over their lifetime. See more on how to use Open Social Security in When to Claim Social Security: How Much Does It Matter, Anyway?

Suppose their incremental income from claiming Social Security falls into the “partial” category, and the effect on their ACA health insurance premium isn’t a big jump, but 10-20% of the incremental income. Then they need to balance the increase in ACA health insurance premiums against the loss in the present value of Social Security benefits if the lower-earning spouse waits until age 65.

$2,000 per month at Full Retirement Age translates to $16,900 per year when the benefits are claimed early at age 62. Suppose receiving $16,900 in Social Security benefits brings 30% of the benefits as incremental income, and it increases their ACA health insurance premiums by 15% of the incremental income. The increase in the ACA health insurance premiums for 3 years is:

$16,900 * 30% * 15% * 3 = $2,282

That’s much less than the $9,470 loss in total present value from delaying claiming until age 65.

On the other hand, if 100% of the $16,900 in Social Security benefits will be incremental income, and it’ll push their income over a cliff, which will increase their ACA health insurance premiums by $2,000 a month, then clearly they should hold off claiming Social Security until they no longer use ACA health insurance.

It All Depends

Claiming Social Security at 62 doesn’t necessarily increase your income for ACA health insurance. In some cases, it can decrease your income and lower your premiums. If it does increase your income, the incremental income isn’t necessarily 100% of the Social Security benefits. It can be only a small percentage of the benefits. The premium increase from the incremental income can be less than the loss in the total present value of Social Security benefits if you choose to delay claiming until 65. Don’t be afraid to claim Social Security at 62 only because it may raise your ACA health insurance premiums.

In some other cases, claiming Social Security at 62 will increase your income by a large percentage of the benefits, which will push it over a cliff and raise your ACA health insurance premiums by a huge amount, possibly more than the Social Security benefits received.

It all depends on whether there’s a cliff, and if so, where your household income is relative to the cliff before and after claiming Social Security. A ramp is much easier to deal with than a cliff.

You should calculate your incremental income based on the income composition before claiming Social Security. Wait to see how the cliff situation will be resolved. Then calculate the effect on your ACA health insurance premiums, and compare with delaying claiming Social Security.

Manage Risk

Finally, laws can change, and your financial situation can change. If you think it’s too risky and you want to avoid any complications, it’s OK to delay claiming Social Security until you no longer use ACA health insurance.

It comes down to “What if I’m wrong?” What if you think you’ll go over a cliff, but you don’t? You delay claiming and unnecessarily lose 1.3% of your Social Security benefits in my example. What if you think you’re safely under the cliff, and you’re suddenly over? You pay a huge amount in ACA health insurance premiums. Losing 1.3% of the lifetime Social Security benefits may be a small price to pay for the peace of mind that your ACA health insurance premiums won’t blow up in your face. See Use Pascal’s Wager When You’re Not Sure About Tax Rules.